Okay, something constructive for a change. I read over the winning openings on the BookEnds mystery contest and a couple of the other blogcontests again, and I’m wondering if I (we) can come up with a snappy opening for the Marfa Lights novel, one that’s more like these. I know I said I didn’t particularly care for the winners, but when in Rome. . . .
The Marfa Lights mystery is sitting with the MWA contest judges right now, but because there are so many entries and I no longer believe that Believing Makes It So, I figure there’s little profit in getting all gut-wrenched about that. Besides, even if I did win that one (see, I’m still delusional–but then that’s what Obama said his followers weren’t, *his* words, and that must be why I’m still undecided on that entire contest, because I’m perma-delusional), it wouldn’t hurt to have a jazzier opening, one like the ones that win contests.
Let’s look at some paraphrases/pastiches of a few of those openers. Now, mine can’t be all that much like these, because I demand that the opening relate to the story I’m about to tell, but we can perhaps get the drift.
(1) “Have you seen the LuckyPenny ads?” June held the free tabloid out in front of her face as though* she were Ricky Ricardo trying to ignore Lucy’s wild dreams again. “Uncle Hezbap is trying to hire himself out as a hitman again!”
* [NOT ONLY a simile, but one in the subjunctive mood as well! Fifty thousand points off!]
I am kind of out of luck on this one, as I don’t have a crazy uncle in the Marfa novel, but we can examine the reasons that the agent said she liked the one that I based this fake upon. (“Upon which I based this pastiche.” See, I like THAT better, but most people think it sounds all uppity.) She said that humor gets her every time. Mark THAT one down on the cover of your Funk and Wagnalls, kids, as I hear that all the time but seldom see it played out in the actual acquisitions of an agent. Somebody with a sub to PUB LUNCH should go look at Jessica’s acquisitions to see whether she really does represent funny/humorous cozies.
(2) Kozmo Mimgraves could smell danger.
She’d smelled that stench so often that she no longer even bothered to wrinkle her nose. However, this time there was something different.
Mmmph. I couldn’t do much of a pastiche on the one I’m imitating here, partly because I felt that the original was SO CLICHED and TIRED. I mean, please! “Danger is my business.” Maybe it’s just me. Yuck. Let’s take a pass on this one. Why didn’t they, though? Can anyone figure it out?
(3) Quinn watched as the prominent vein on Sol’s forehead pulsated* and the birthmark on the side of his face shaded gradually towards maroon. He continued kicking that poor slob in the ribs to keep him face-flat on the pavement, but what was she supposed to do about it? You didn’t wanna cross Sol. He bent down and slurped the guy’s left ear into his mouth, then slapped his teeth together. Sol’s laughter swellled as he stood above the body, blood trickling out of the corner of his mouth.
* [I resisted the temptation to add “to the tune of Madonna’s ‘Like a Virgin’.” Aren’t you proud of me?]
Yuck, yuck, yuck. I didn’t change this one as much as I did the others. And I find the POV character completely cowardly and unlik[e]able. I don’t know if you could bite an ear off and then laugh while you had it on your tongue without choking, either, and would there be that much blood from cartilage? It doesn’t bleed at all when you pierce ears. See what the passage did to me? It made me doubt the logistics of the horrific act. Besides, I think we’re in the middle of a scene for no good reason. In order to understand why Sol did this and who the girl is and how we got here, somebody’s going to have to either do a flashback or an infodump. If the infodump is done via having someone walk up and demand to know, in a Babylon-5 outtake sort of way, “Just what is going on around here,” it’ll still be lame. If it’s done by way of the cops taking the girl’s statement, that MIGHT work. Still, I just don’t LIKE this.
In fact, I couldn’t find any openings on any agent’s contest that I particularly liked.
However, I probably do need to hoosh up my first few lines. They might be TOO cozy. What could I do to signal to readers that there’s going to be a chase across the Marfan desert with some ghost lights that are out to swallow up my heroine’s car? And that she’s gonna get schmoozed by an off-kilter preacher man?
Yeah, the opening lines I quote below are fairly ZZZZ-making, I suppose. Still, I don’t want to promise what I’m not gonna deliver. I wanted to stay away from the philosophical focus-in opening that I sometimes do (you know the drill–we start out musing about some philosophical thing and then go to the scene.) I didn’t want to have slapstick stuff or open with a weird jolt.
Maybe I’m just not cut out for this business.
My sister was arguing with me about the “right” way to roll paint onto her dining room walls when the phone rang.
“That’s for me.” I started backing down the stepladder.
Zoë always let her machine pick up, so she didn’t object. She stepped back for a better view and pushed back her dark hair, leaving a skunk-streak of vanilla paint through her bangs. “You’re not supposed to paint W’s. I don’t care what they did on ‘Trading Spaces.’ Just go straight up and down, overlapping the edges a bit.” She demonstrated with her fuzzy roller; she’d gotten the longer stick and was taller besides, so she had her feet firmly on the floor. “Who would be calling you here?”
*sigh* Any suggestions? We want to arrive in this scene fairly quickly, because the phone call is about the murder. Yay, murder, something mystery readers like!
Ah, but let us look again at the opening sentence of one of the big winners of the contest. It seemed like a complete cliche and re-run to me, as it echoes the title of at least one film and a couple of thrillers. But hey, wadda I know. Let us attempt to take inspiration from this, a pale pastiche of the true opening.
Sarah Jane Fernbeck was dressed to kill. (*ouch! Bad enough, buddit goze on*) She liked the sound of that. Purrrrrrr. Glancing around the bar, she slid off the barstool and into the lap of the guy next door, in mid-pat. “Hello, Sailor.”
Okay, the real opening that I was copying doesn’t have the “Hello, Sailor” bit or anything from “Purrr” on, but I didn’t wanna be plagiarizing too closely, as someone might be watching (though I doubt it!)
I feel we could steal THAT and riff on it, as it is DEFINITELY A CLICHE that has been heard before. Surely (Shirley) I can get away with retyping it with a twist, or even a twist-tie.
Let’s see what kind of wacky opening I can get out of this. I feel that “dressed to kill” is fair game. If you don’t think so, let us discuss it in the comments. Let us reason together. Meantime, take a gander at this.
Ariadne French and her sister weren’t dressed to KILL, but possibly the sight of them could MAIM . . . or more likely BLIND . . . at least make you NEARSIGHTED or all squinty like Pee Wee Herman’s best buddy . . . (GROSS–now you see why I don’t go there. STOP STOP STOP)
Okay, trying again.
Ariadne French and her sister Zoe weren’t dressed to KILL, but possibly the sight of them could MAIM . . . or more likely BLIND . . . well, at least make a man NEARSIGHTED, if he caught sight of them in the fading afternoon light wearing their finest grubbies, splattered with paint, and glowing with perspiration (because Southern ladies don’t drip with sweat; their mother had made certain of that.)
Everybody else is out on the town dancing and having fun, or over at the con and filking up a storm, and I am sitting here making up stupid new opening lines to my novel. Is that not pathetic? It is pathetic. The great Oz has spoken.
Any ideas at all. . . .
“I’d sell out, but nobody’s buying!”–SC